Security Beat 

U.S. Court Blocks Enforcement of Personnel Rules 

10  2,005 

By Joe Pappalardo 

A federal judge has barred the Department of Homeland Security from implementing major portions of its new personnel system.

When DHS was created, Congress gave the secretary of DHS and the director of the Office of Personnel Management the unusual authority to develop a separate human-resources management system. That authority, according to court documents, was not bound by “the constraints imposed by the civil service laws that normally govern employees in the competitive service of the federal government.”

Congress mandated that the system be flexible and ensure the ability of employees to bargain collectively. A slew of unions, which collectively represent approximately 60,000 DHS employees, challenged the regulations for allegedly failing to comply with these congressional requirements and for creating disciplinary methods exceeding the authority of the DHS agencies.

The district court judge for the District of Columbia, Rosemary M. Collyer, ruled in August that “significant aspects of the human-resources system fail to conform to the express dictates of the Homeland Security Act,” which created the department.

Specifically, she enjoined DHS from implementing the entire labor-management relations section of the new regulations, as well as a section dealing with employee appeals that precluded mitigation of penalties except in cases where the “penalty is so disproportionate to the basis for the action as to be wholly without justification.”

DHS cannot implement the portions of its regulations unless an appellate court overturns this ruling on appeal. Alternatively, DHS can also choose to issue entirely new regulations.

The unions and employee-advocacy groups hailed the injunction as a needed protection for workers’ rights, but opponents said that the lack of penalties for poorly performing DHS employees would degrade the department and make employees less accountable for their actions.

DHS employees will continue to be covered by existing provisions until the matter is settled.

The Department of Homeland Security is releasing a series of requests for technologies that can reveal what vessels are approaching U.S. shores and what they are carrying. The requests illustrate holes in existing port and maritime protection, and what DHS officials envision for the nation’s future waterside security, said Coast Guard Cmdr. Joseph Vojvodich, portfolio manger for maritime domain-awareness research.

“It’s not enough to collect more data or radar dots,” he said.

A particular emphasis needs to be put on standoff-detection devices that can sniff out contraband at more than 50 feet. Tools to identify people and ships also are necessary, including cooperative and uncooperative vessels.

The science and technology directorate at DHS is starting several programs to fill some of these gaps, said Leslee Shumway, DHS’ program manager for maritime research and development.

New projects include a command-sector simulation that can train commanders how to process reams of data. The simulation also will serve as a test bed for new data integration tools in development, she said. Another urgently anticipated project is a blue-force tracking system to chart the deployment of friendly forces in a busy environment. The system, when developed, will be demonstrated in the Port of New York, Shumway added.

Other programs include an ambient radar-tracking system, a portable entanglement net to bring non-lethal stopping power to boats and helicopters, and new sensors for the P-3 Orion aircraft used by customs officials.

  Bookmark and Share