Army aviators—rehashing lessons garnered in Vietnam and seizing on recent
experience gained in Iraq and Afghanistan —are forcing a revolution in
combat helicopter training.
Armed with hard won know-how, veteran pilots are returning to flight schools
to pass on an array of new combat tactics and flight techniques.
While Pentagon officials hesitate to compare the war in Iraq with Vietnam,
when it comes to employing helicopters in battle, tactics used in that war are
coming in handy. Operation Iraqi Freedom is redefining the way attack helicopters
are being used, especially in urban environments, said pilots.
The Army is training its crews “to fight the aircraft to the limits of
its capability,” Col. Mark Ferrell, director of training and doctrine
simulation for Army aviation at Fort Rucker, Ala., told National Defense during
an Army Aviation Association convention.
The flight school is introducing a complete “culture change” by
starting to teach maneuvering flight, something that has not been taught for
decades, according to Lt. Gen. Richard Cody, Army deputy chief of staff.
The architects of a new modular aviation force are planning to create a structure
that would allow pilots to go from one fight to another without losing their
situational awareness. That only can happen with the integration of aviation
and ground forces, said Cody. This is something with which the Army experimented
during the Iraq war, and now is formally implementing.
While new doctrine manuals will be rolling off the presses as early as next
fall, and working drafts are due out this summer, gaps will remain in the training
of conventional aviators when it comes to operations in city settings. Aviators
do not have a full-scale facility where they can train for military operations
in urban terrain (MOUT), said Col. Greg Gass, an assault commander with the
101st Airborne Division.
“We need to try to develop some type of MOUT training facility for aviators,”
said Gass. It does not mean that such facilities do not exist, but they do not
replicate cities the size of Najaf or Karbala, in Iraq, with populations of
at least 600,000 people, according to Gass. Most importantly, it is the conventional
forces that need to get this training, he added. “It will pay off in the
end.”
To close up the gap, homecoming pilots impart their knowledge and experience
from both Iraq and Afghanistan. Training with the new tactics, techniques and
procedures will start at the level of Flight School XXI, the Army’s refurbished
pilot training curriculum.
The changes that Ferrell’s directorate will be implementing are, in big
part, tactics that “anyone coming out of Vietnam can do every day,”
he said. “What we have learned is that we have gone for about 10 years
not teaching those old skills that we learned in Vietnam. We just quit doing
it.”
Aware of the Army’s superiority at night, the enemy now chooses the time
of day and the place of the fight, said Ferrell. Therefore, maneuvering flight
for attack helicopters and the Kiowa Warrior OH-58 D—used for reconnaissance—is
going back into the curriculum, said Ferrell.
“We pretty much trained a generation of Army aviators that do very well
at night in a hovering static fight,” he said. “The enemy has a
vote, and they will vote not to fight us at night now. To take away that advantage,
they will do things that will force us to fight in daylight. Well, you can’t
do that static out of hover. You have to be maneuvering.”
Many of the Vietnam-era tactics had to be re-learned, said Farrell, but “fortunately,
we still have a lot of experience that we are able to draw from,” he said.
That expertise comes from seasoned pilots, as well as the Special Operations
Aviation Regiment and the 101st Airborne Division, which continued those practices,
because of the missions they had to perform. However, those procedures did not
spill across the entire spectrum of Army aviation.
The prime effort of Brig. Gen. Edward Sinclair, commander of the Army Aviation
Center at Fort Rucker, is to bring people in like CW-4 Lee Muckleroy, of the
101st, who most recently flew Apaches in Iraq, back to Fort Rucker to instruct
new pilots. “By fall, you will see a tremendous amount of combat experience
in Fort Rucker,” said Ferrell.
As an instructor at Fort Rucker, Muckleroy said he would stress the importance
of rigorous mission planning, because there is no substitute.
“I would plan 18 hours for a two-hour mission, and try to think of all
the things that may go wrong before I take off the ground,” he said in
a talk with reporters. It is imperative to have as much information as possible
before the choppers go out on a mission, he added.
Just because the Apache Longbows are digital aircraft, it does not mean that
planning goes down the drain, while everything else is determined by a computer,
he said. “We need to triple-check it, we need to go over it, and teach
them how to ask the right questions, give them the information, make them interface
with the ground element.”
Weapon delivery techniques are another critical item in Muckleroy’s book.
He would be “making sure guys know the different types of weapons that
the aircraft carries, their ranges, their usage,” he said. “The
most important thing we do is put rounds down range to help the ground guy,
and if those young pilots do not know that information backwards and forwards,
then they can’t do the job.”
Muckleroy was one of the few Army aviators to go through training at the National
Guard’s High-Altitude Army Training Site in Eagle, Colo. He cannot stress
enough how crucial that training was for his missions in Iraq. That one-week,
super-intensive course teaches pilots power management.
HAATS teaches helicopter pilots to calculate the power available in their helicopters
based on the environment and mission they have to perform. HAATS teaches pilots
a method that accurately predicts the power necessary for certain missions.
The pilots learn how to use tabular data, which gives the pilots more precision
for their decisions.
Usually pilots train at near-sea levels, where power management does not crop
up as an issue because aircraft are not pushed to their maximum power levels.
That, however, changes in mountainous area such as Afghanistan or the border
between Iraq and Iran. Often, when pilots find themselves at 10,000 feet, they
also find themselves exceeding the power limit-which leads to accidents.
Despite the fact that the power management taught at HAATS proves to be effective,
it isn’t taught across the Army. Unit commanders, in fact, have to push
hard to get the resources to send a handful of pilots there.
“Our CW-5 found out about it, and he went and came back, and said ‘That
is the best training that I have ever been to,’” Muckleroy recalled.
“He fought tooth and nail to get us up there. When they said no, he fought,
and the battalion commander decided to do it, and send five people, all senior
instructors. I got to land up at 14,200 feet, and I did not think it was possible.”
With high gross weight and high temperatures, the power available in the helicopter’s
engine is going to be a lot less. “But if you learn how to operate your
aircraft in those conditions, and you train yourself to always think about ‘okay,
I only have this much power because I weigh this much,’” problems
can be avoided.
Once immersed in a hot climate such as Iraq, pilots would be able to determine
whether they would be able to hover over the ground, for example, Muckleroy
said. “When they are going to the mission they are already planning, ‘How
am I going to do a racetrack pattern? How am I going to do running fire? How
much fuel do I have to burn off?’”
Army aviators must respond to the soldiers on the ground at the drop of a hat,
said Muckleroy. “We do not have the luxury of operating at night only,
because when the ground guy calls, we go now,” he said. “They do
not want to hear that you do not have enough power. They do not want to hear
it is too hot.” According to Muckleroy, some of this training is going
to be incorporated into the flight school program at Fort Rucker.
Learning how to fly at a reduced power margin also diminishes brownout incidents.
Brownout is caused by the rotors kicking up so much dust that it is impossible
to land or take off at times, contributing to a series of deadly accidents.
Muckleroy’s unit trained to fly with reduced power not only in the actual
helicopters, but also in the simulators.
“We also simulated high altitude and low power settings and high-gross
weights. We would make them take off at max-gross weights and have them fly
up to 10,000 feet,” he said. “So, when we had to go do Iranian border
missions at 8,000 feet, we knew which pilots we would be taking. We took qualified
instructors. We took guys who were experienced and did well in the simulator
at Fort Campbell.”
According to Muckleroy, the Iraqi deployment revealed “some of the worst
conditions I have ever seen. I have been to Desert Storm, and I had been to
Kuwait,” he said. Landing conditions were so bad that they had to put
their birds down by using symbology, the picture displayed over the pilot’s
right eye. “The young guys do not have the experience to do that yet,”
he said.
Therefore, the team mix on the helicopter was critical, he said. “You
do not put two junior guys in a $35 million helicopter and say, ‘Okay,
we trust you to bring it back with no problem,’” he added.
Adding to the complex battlefield in Iraq was the constant threat of man-portable
air defense systems, or manpads.
Even though the infrared signature coming out of the Apache engines is low,
the anti-missile protection system needs a considerable improvement, he said.
Meanwhile, to avoid the newer generation of manpads, the pilots learned to fly
faster, reduce their exposure time, avoid large built-up areas, and made sure
to fly different routes and avoid flying directly over villages, Muckleroy said.
“You do not walk up to a rabid dog and slap it on the head,” he
added.
The use of deception, said Lt. Col. Doug Gobram, increases survivability and
aides aerial maneuver. All possible enablers must be used to ensure mission
success, he said in a presentation. “Use the other guy’s ammunition
first,” he said.
In urban environments, the 101st always has worked with the inner- and outer-ring
concepts, said Gass. At first, the inner ring of the city is secured, and forces
start moving towards the outer ring, he explained. “It is a tactic that
we worked for years and years,” he said. However, they worked on this
procedure with the Apaches, but never the way they handled it in Iraq.
“What we ended up doing was establishing the inner ring with our Kiowa
Warriors, and then task organize them also to the main efforts,” Gass
said. “The Apaches did outstanding work outside the town to prevent either
infiltrators or exfiltrators. They were able to better use the long-range radars,
so they were of better use on the outer rings.
For fights in bustling cities, the wingman concept, revived in the war in Afghanistan,
proved to be golden, aviators said. It is “absolutely critical, especially
in a city fight where you do not know where the next guy is going to shoot you
from. You have to have somebody to cover your steps,” one pilot pointed
out. This concept also is used increasingly in desert environments, primarily
because it is difficult for helicopters to hover.
While detailed route planning is critical, a flexible and simple plan is also
key to mission success, Gobram said. In addition, without constant training,
even during deployments, missions risk failure, he stressed.
The role of attack helicopters in urban environments is going to be redefined,
he said. At first glance, running fire is going to be incorporated more into
missions, because the days of hovering fire are over, he told National Defense.
“We have to keep moving, especially any time you are in a built-up area,”
he said. “If you stop, somebody is going to put an RPG [rocket propelled
grenade] up your ass. It is easy to sneak up on a helicopter.”
The connection to the troops on the ground has to be strong, said Gobram, and
that is achieved by having an aviation liaison officer embedded with the ground
troops. These liaison operators are sent to “understand what the ground
guy is going through,” said Gobram.
Having a liaison officer “gives the guy in the air the comfort factor
that they are talking to somebody that can talk airplanes to them,” said
Maj. Jim Abrams, also with the 101st. The Apaches provided presence for the
infantrymen, said Gobram. “Sometimes that presence is hard to quantify,”
he said in an interview. “In the middle of the night, when [the soldiers]
are doing a raid and our Apaches are sitting in over watch a kilometer off.
You can’t see them, but you can hear them. It makes that infantryman feel
that he has Apaches on station.”
Also, in order to have a flexible and agile aviation force that can jump from
one fight to another without losing its situational awareness, the right liaison
officers have to be embedded with the ground troops, Cody told reporters. According
to him, the 101st embraced that concept in the 1970s and early 1980s, but the
subsequent downsizing of the Army did not allow for that to continue.
Now, as the Army is going through yet another restructuring, it is looking
to add these liaison officers without extra growth, said Cody. The Army is looking
to embed an aviation cell with each of the maneuver brigades, “so that
they can be adaptable,” he said.
The war in Iraq also has seen the emergence of split-based operations. “Typically,
you want to keep the whole battalion together working out of the same area,
because you have to have all your maintenance, and all the support structure
and logistics piece,” said Abrams. “We are going to see a lot more
split-based operations, because of the greater battle space, greater distances
and working for different people.”
With split-based operations, about two-thirds of the battalion was kept in
the same place, while two attack companies were sent 230 kilometers apart. Maintenance
had to be provided “back and forth” between the two locations, he
said.
Ultimately, when it comes to taking off for a combat mission, rules of engagement
have to be understood in the cockpit as well, “because we have young pilots
making political and in some cases strategic decisions in whether they pull
the trigger or not,” he said. “Everybody needs to understand the
rules of engagement, because many times you do not have time to call back to
three levels up to get a division commander.”